Why is Wikipedia
Censoring Me? (Another hidden holocaust)
by James Bacque – Serendipity
In 1989, I published the first in a series of books about the
Second World War and its aftermath. The first, Other Losses, showed the
tremendous atrocities committed against enemy prisoners in the prison
camps of the US and France after 1945. The next, Just Raoul, was a
biography of a hero of the French Resistance who saved many refugees
from Nazi death camps. The next, Crimes and Mercies, described the full
extent of all allied crimes against Germans, plus the wonderful charity
work of Canada and the USA in saving 800 million people, including
Germans, Japanese and Italians, from starving to death in the hungry
years after 1945. The next, Dear Enemy, illuminated the attitudes of
the western allies to Germany from 1945 to now.
Wikipedia reviews and criticizes only Other Losses, and in
such a biased way, that I finally tried to correct their many errors.
Starting in March 2006, I tried repeatedly over many weeks to correct
the errors, but found that within a day at first, then within hours,
and finally within minutes, some Wikipedian editor had expunged my
corrections, replacing them with ever more hostile and denigrating
allegations. Friends of mine tried also to correct the flawed Wikipedia
article, but found the same situation. Finally we decided that
Wikipedia was deliberately censoring my contributions, and that it was
pointless to continue trying to present the facts on Wikipedia. After
Serendipity (already acquainted with censorship at Wikipedia) heard of
this situation I was offered the chance to publish the real story,
which appears below.
Wikipedia quotes Stephen E. Ambrose as saying that
<>Other Losses<> is "... spectacularly flawed ..." without
saying that Ambrose also wrote that "You have made a major historical
discovery which will ... span the oceans and have reverberations for
decades, yea centuries to come. You have the goods on these guys ..."
Wikipedia does not say that Ambrose changed his mind only
after he was retained by the US Army to lecture at the War College in
Pennsylvania. Nor does Wikipedia mention that in his attack on me in
the New York Times, he admitted that he had not done the necessary
research to reach the conclusions that he published in that same
article. Wikipedia fails to mention that the Ambrose it cites as an
authority admitted that he had plagiarized several other authors.
Wikipedia does not concern itself with the accusations that Ambrose
stole work from a graduate student, which he published as his own.
Wikipedia ignores my book, Crimes and Mercies, which goes far
towards balancing the record of western actions after World War Two.
The book shows the great charity extended by the western allies,
chiefly Canada and the USA, towards the starving around the world after
WW2, including the Japanese and Germans. Saying that the overwhelming
majority of professional historians reject my work, and citing as an
authority one historian who has never worked in this field,
Wikipedia ignores the support given me by the eminent US Army
military historian Col. Dr. Ernest F. Fisher, a former Senior Historian
of the US Army Centre for Military History, Washington. Fisher, a
professional historian for decades, wrote the official US Army history
of the campaign in Italy. He assisted me for months in researching
documents in the US National Archives, wrote the Introduction to my
book Other Losses, and has supported me with public statements for the
seventeen years since its first publication. He helped me for many
months researching in the archives.
Wikipedia does not mention the expert editing, research help
and public support given me by the eminent epidemiologist and
biostatistician, Dr Anthony B. Miller, former head of the Department of
Biostatistics at the University of Toronto.
Wikipedia also casts aside the support given my work by
Richard Overy, King's College, University of London; Otto Kimminich,
University of Regensburg; Dr Alfred De Zayas, author of many books on
postwar German history; Prof. Dr. Peter Hoffmann, McGill University,
author of the most expert books on the German resistance; Prof. J. K.
Johnson, Carleton University, Ottawa; Professor Ralph Raico, University
of Buffalo; Prof. Ed Peterson, University of Wisconsin; Prof Ralph
Scott, University of Iowa; Prof. Pierre Van Den Berghe, University of
Seattle; Prof. Dr Richard Mueller, former head, Department of English,
University of Aachen; Prof. Hans Koch, University of York and many
others.
Among writers who have approved my work and supported me are
Julian Barnes; Nikolai Tolstoy; John Fraser, Master of Massey College,
Toronto; John Bemrose of Toronto; Robert Kroetsch, Winnipeg; and many
others. My work has been published around in the world in ten languages
by Macmillan, Little, Brown, Prima, Ullstein, Editions Sand, McClelland
and Stewart, New Press, and many many others.
Finally, the most glaring omission is that the massive and
detailed KGB Archives in Moscow have millions of documents whose
evidence completely confirms the statistical work in Other Losses. The
math is simple: about 1.5 million German prisoners alive in allied
prison camps at the end of the war never came home, nor were their
deaths reported to the German government, their families, the
International Red Cross or the UN. The figure was determined by the
Adenauer government in Germany, submitted to the UN, and has never been
disputed by anyone. Thus when Other Losses came out in 1989, alleging
deaths of about one million in French and American camps that left
about 500,000 to be accounted for. They could have died only in the KGB
camps, because there were not half a million prisoners in any other
camps in the world. Thus, in effect Other Losses was predicting that
when the communists opened the KGB archives, they would show deaths of
about 500,000. And lo and behold, when Gorbachev brought down the
communist rule, and the archives were opened, I went there, and found
the Bulanov Report which showed that 356,687 Germans died in Soviet
captivity, plus another 93,900 civilians taken as substitutes for dead
or escaped prisoners for a total of 450,587
This astonishing discovery is not mentioned in Wikipedia, nor
by any other of the "professional historians." Except one, Stefan
Karner, who went to the KGB archives, saw the evidence piled up in
enormous quantities, and said he did not believe it. Instead, he
preferred to publish his own "estimates," which confirm the
conventional view.
Information about books written by James Bacque may be found
on his website World War 2 Books.
Mass Starvation of Germans 1945-1950
Censorship at Wikipedia
http://serendipity.li/hr/bacque_on_wikipedia.htm
No comments:
Post a Comment
Anything to say about anything.....